Is it illegal for employers to ask newcomers about their lack of Canadian work experience?

A lack of Canadian experience is a common barrier identified by newcomers as they pursue meaningful work in their new country.The Ontario Human Rights commission identified other barriers that immigrants experience when finding jobs that correspond with their education, skills and experience. These can include:

Employers not recognizing foreign credentials and experience

Language and communication difficulties

Employers not being helpful integrating the employee into the workplace and not providing job-related learning opportunities

Being rejected for positions because they are thought to be “overqualified”

Arbitrary requirements for “Canadian experience”

Outright discrimination

According to the Canadian Human Rights Act, it is illegal for a federal-sector employer to ask candidates about their age, sex or gender, sexual orientation, gender identity and expression, marital status, family status, race, color, religion and mental or physical disability.

 

Most employers in Canada are considered private and governed by provincial legislation rather than federal. However, provincial laws generally mirror the federal ones and reflect the Canadian Human Rights Act.

 

Human rights tribunals have held that “Canadian experience” questions may constitute discrimination, unless that kind of experience is a real and legitimate occupational requirement.

 

When an employer requires applicants applying for jobs to have Canadian work experience this can be considered discrimination based on grounds such as race, ancestry, place of origin and ethic origin.

 

The Ontario Human Rights Commission has published a guide titled “Removing the “Canadian experience” barrier – A guide for employers and regulatory bodies”, which states that requiring Canadian work experience could violate the Ontario Human Rights Code. The guide sets out how to make sure job requirements are legitimate and best practices for employers and regulatory bodies to follow.

 

What is an employer allowed to ask me?

Employers are allowed to ask questions about your qualifications and your ability to do the job. For example, if you need a driver’s license for a job, an employer can ask you if you have one.

 

An employer is also permitted to ask if you have been convicted of a crime, and can ask you to get a police record check.

 

Although an employer is not allowed to ask if you have Canadian work experience, they can ask you if you are legally allowed to work in Canada.

 

Employment rights in Canada

There are laws across Canada in place to protect workers. The rights of foreign workers in Canada are also protected under federal and provincial/territorial labour laws.

 

Canadian workers have the right to be fairly treated in the workplace free from discrimination.

 

The Canadian Human Rights Act prohibits discrimination on the basis of gender, race, ethnicity and other grounds. This also applies permanent residents and those working in Canada on a work or study visa.

Source: cicnews.com




Related articles

Visitors no longer allowed to apply for work permits from within Canada

As of August 28, temporary residents in Canada on a visitor visa are no longer permitted to apply for a job-supported work permit from within Canada.
The temporary policy allowing visitors to apply for these work permits was introduced in August 2020 to assist some visitors in Canada who were unable to return home because of border closures related to the COVID-19 pandemic—with the further aim of aiding employers to fill key labour gaps, by allowing some visitors who met certain conditions to apply for an job-supported work permit from inside Canada.

Quebec announces suspension of LMIA processing for some low-wage temporary foreign workers

Starting September 3rd, the processing of Labour Market Impact Assessments (LMIAs) to applicants in Montréal will be suspended for job offers with hourly wages below $27.47 CAD (the Quebec median hourly wage). This measure is expected to be in place for the next six months and has been approved by the federal government of Canada.

How long will it take to become a permanent resident of Canada in 2024?

Foreign nationals seeking permanent residence (PR) in Canada often look for the fastest pathway to achieving their goal and starting a new life in this country.
On a basic level, Canada has four primary immigration classes: economic immigration, family-class sponsorship, humanitarian/compassionate immigration and immigration for refugees/protected persons.
However, within those four general classifications, Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) provides foreign nationals with more than 100 ways to immigrate to Canada.

Finding a job in Ontario

Recently the Ontario provincial government chose to make it illegal for employers to require Canadian work experience in their job advertisements, in addition to making it mandatory for all job postings to feature salaries.
Both steps represent victories, not just for the Ontario labour force (who will now be able to see how the potential salary of a job compares to provincial and national averages); but especially for newcomers to Ontario—who are often held back from roles and professions they are qualified for, based on their lack of Canadian experience.
Considering these two changes, CIC News has compiled the following guide for newcomers looking for a job in Ontario.

Ontario looking to ban employers from requiring Canadian work experience on application forms and in job postings

In a first-of-its-kind move among all Canadian provinces and territories, Ontario has announced its intention to introduce new legislation that would, if passed, ban employers from requiring “Canadian work experience … in job postings or application forms.”
Announced today, Ontario’s Ministry of Labour, Immigration, Training and Skills Development hopes this new legislation will help more newcomers fill in-demand labour shortages across the province.

Canadian federal court denies work permit based on IELTS score

A citizen of Iran was a home design and renovation manager for seven years. In 2022, she signed an employment contract to work as a Residential Home Builder with a construction company located in Vancouver. The job duties and responsibilities included planning and preparing work schedules, selecting and employing trade subcontractors and managing budgets.